By now, this battle is fairly familiar. Transit advocates argue for better transit systems while opponents are quick to say "Americans will never give up their cars". But here's the thing.

No one is asking you, or anyone else to give up their car.

Not today.
Not tomorrow.
Not secretly in some planning back room.

It seems like every time transit comes up, the reaction is the same.
Defensive. Suspicious. Emotional.

“Why are you trying to force everyone onto buses?”
“I need my car.”
“Not everyone can take transit.”
“Stop telling people how to live.”

But what get's lost in translation is a very important, crucial even, point. Transit advocacy is not about taking cars away. It’s about giving people options.

Right now, in most American cities, you don’t actually have the option to move. Not even close. You can argue that we have cars and because of it, we can move. But when a car is the only way you can travel effectively in a city, that's not really an option..is it.

And we’ve confused the two for so long that any attempt to fix it feels like an attack.

Let’s be clear about what transit advocates are not saying.

They are not saying you should sell your car.
They are not saying cars should disappear.
They are not saying everyone should commute the same way.

They are saying something much simpler and much more reasonable:

Your car should be a choice, not a requirement.

There’s a big difference...huge.

If you love driving, great! Drive away...if you can afford it.
If your job requires a vehicle, that’s real.
If you live in a rural area, cars make sense.

Transit advocacy does not deny any of that.

What it challenges is the idea that every trip, for every person, in every place, must be done by car or else life falls apart.

For decades, we built places where driving was the only mode taken seriously. Roads got funding. Transit got scraps. Sidewalks were optional. Buses were slow by design. Trains were treated as luxuries.

Then we pointed at the results and said, “See? Nobody uses transit.”

Of course they don’t.
We didn’t build it to work!

Imagine applying that logic anywhere else.

Imagine building a school with no teachers and then saying education doesn’t work.
Imagine running water only twice a day and declaring plumbing a failure.
Imagine designing a road with potholes every ten feet and using that as proof cars aren’t viable.

Transit fails when it’s set up to fail.

And in many places, it is.

Buses stuck in the same traffic as cars.
Routes that don’t go where people need to go.
Schedules that make being late inevitable.
Stops with no shelter, no lighting, no dignity.

When people say “transit doesn’t work here,” what they usually mean is “we never gave it a fair shot.”

Bad transit doesn’t create choice.
Good transit does.

A legitimate transit system changes how a city functions, even for people who never step on a bus or train.

Fewer cars on the road means less congestion for drivers.
Reliable transit gives people an alternative on days they don’t want to drive.
It gives teenagers independence.
It gives older adults mobility.
It gives people with disabilities real access.
It gives workers a backup when their car breaks down.

Right now, in many cities, losing access to a car means losing access to life.

Your job.
Your groceries.
Your healthcare.
Your community.

I know because that's what the data shows...and I've also been there.

Many are chained to a fragile system held together by monthly payments, insurance bills, and hope that nothing goes wrong.

When someone advocates for transit, what they’re really saying is:

People deserve a backup plan that actually works.

Cars are expensive.
They’re the second-largest household expense for most families.
And yet we act like choosing not to drive is some kind of moral failing.

If transit were reliable, frequent, and safe, many people would use it sometimes. Not always. Sometimes.

That’s the key word everyone skips over.

Sometimes.

No one is asking you to take the bus to Costco with a week’s worth of groceries if that doesn’t make sense.
No one is saying you can’t road-trip, haul supplies, or drive when you want to.

They’re saying maybe you shouldn’t have to drive every single time you leave your house.

Maybe a trip downtown doesn’t require finding parking.
Maybe a commute doesn’t require sitting in traffic twice a day.
Maybe a teenager can get to school or work without a parent rearranging their life.

That’s not control.
That’s flexibility.

The fear around transit often comes from a deeper place.

People are afraid of losing autonomy.
They’re afraid of being told what to do.
They’re afraid of change that feels imposed rather than chosen.

And to be fair, those fears are real. But they’re aimed at the wrong thing.

A city with strong transit doesn’t reduce autonomy, it actually increases it.

You can drive when you want and take transit when you don’t.
You can walk when it’s pleasant or bike when it makes sense.

That’s what choice looks like.

What we have now is not choice. It's more like compulsion wrapped in familiarity.

We’ve normalized a system where opting out isn’t realistic, and then we defend that system as freedom. Transit advocacy is about correcting that imbalance. To show that a legitimate transit system isn’t anti-car but anti-no-options.

And here’s the part that should matter even if you never plan to ride transit.

Every person who can take transit is one less car in front of you. Every trip shifted off the road makes driving better for the people who remain. Transit is congestion relief, whether you ride it or not.

Really, it's simple math.

Cities that invest in transit don’t eliminate cars. They stop designing everything around the assumption that everyone will always drive, and start designing around how people actually live.

People of different ages, abilities, needs, days.

The real question isn’t “Why are you pushing transit?”

It’s “Why are we so committed to a system that gives people no alternatives?”

No one is asking you to give up your car. They’re asking why your car has to be your only viable option. They’re asking why freedom only seems to count when it comes with a steering wheel.

At the end of the day, transit advocacy it’s about building a city resilient enough to support choice.

And once people experience that kind of freedom, the fear tends to fade.

Because having options doesn’t take anything away.

It gives people their lives back, one trip at a time.

‍